A few weeks ago, I very timidly ventured into the “online shopping for a DSLR” arena. I wasn’t sure I was going to make the switch, but I started seriously considering it.
And so began the inevitable Canon-or-Nikon debate. One day, I was sure I’d stick to Canon, and have the luxury of being able to use all my old film lenses. I’ve always been a Canon girl. Then another day, I was excited about the thought of making the switch to Nikon, with its punchy straight-out-of-camera shots and vivid colors.
Through all this back and forth between camera systems, I had to keep in mind that everything had to conform to a budget. A budget that slowly crept its way into scary territory. It still hovers there. Sometimes, it enters my dreams at night and I wake up in a sweat. Then I check my bank balance online, and manage to breathe normally again.
Welcome to my world.
Then, just yesterday, I saw these.
Jaw drop moment #1. Now granted, that’s Scott Kelby taking the photographs, and I am fully aware of the sad reality that no camera in the world can make me shoot pictures like he does. But, come on. These are practically straight-out-of-camera.
Do me a favor. Head over to Scott Kelby’s blog and check out his vacation photos. Those are mostly handheld, save for the sunset shots. Tell me those crisp colors, sharpness and vibrance don’t just jump off the page.
It thrilled me no end to find out that he took these with his Nikon D300 and the kit lens that comes with it (or at least it’s the lens that Costco offers along with the body).
The D300 just happened to be on my wishful thinking list of candidates, and his post just propelled it to the top position. And there it sat, pushing the limits of my budget, which was screaming for a restoration of sanity in my world of paltry finances.
Then. Then, then, then. I happen upon the video below. And my jaw dropped again. If you can, view it in HD. The compressed video below is stunning enough, but it just doesn’t do the actual footage justice.
That was from Dan Chung, a Guardian photographer. I couldn’t believe that was shot with a Canon DSLR and lenses on manual focus. The video was so clean, even though it was shot at night. You’d be hard-pressed to find any noise in there. This camera instantly impressed the socks off me.
Of course, I have no illusions of ever finding some hidden inner talent for cinematography. But didn’t that clip make you want to go out and shoot videos all day? And night?
I dug around a little more, and found this amazing video shot by the equally amazing Vincent Laforet. Again, with the aforementioned Canon 5D Mark II. With absolutely no file manipulation save for compression. Did you see the footage shot from a chopper? Incredible. Simply incredible.
Sigh. My poor jaw.
Thankfully, all this camera-comparison won’t actually affect me in a real way. It’s way deep into scary budget territory. And yes, I do pay attention to those screams for fiscal sanity in my head. My head can sometimes get obnoxiously loud, and no matter how much I want to tune it out, it still holds ultimate control over my wallet.
It’s almost a good thing that I don’t have the luxury of buying any camera I want. Otherwise, I’d be glued to this screen for days. ‘Cause, well, that’s how I am. I have this obsessive need to launch thorough research efforts, exhaust all possibilities, and explore all probable consequences before making any major decisions. Which, I guess, is the reason I try not to make any major decisions whatsoever.
(And no, the problem wouldn’t be solved by suddenly being able to afford to buy both systems. Because I’d still end up favoring one, which means the other will spend a lot of time just laying there, pathetically underutilized. And I truly, truly loathe waste.)
For now, I’m still happy with my little Canon Powershot S5 point-and-shoot. So I’m not sure I want to go ahead and add a DSLR to my arsenal. I’m kinda loyal to my equipment, and sometimes, I imagine my camera sitting on the table, hurting inside because it heard me getting all excited about these new DSLRs. I know. I’m weird like that.
If there’s one thing this whole what-if shopping has taught me, it’s that these are exciting times to get into photography. There is a wealth of choices available, across every price range, and however excruciating the process of decision-making, you really can’t go wrong with whatever ends up being your final pick.
I like not going wrong. I’m kinda normal like that.
Given what you can do with your humble Powershot S5, it would be scary crazy to see what you could do with one of these DSLRs.
I gotta say you do amazing stuff with your little point and shoot. Nothing wrong with staying right there.
I went through the same dilemmas when I purchased my advanced point and shoot. Believe me, after you do all that research you just gotta put the camera in your hand to see if it speaks to you in your own special language. That is how you pick. You already know all those cameras can turn out great photos.
There are days when I really miss my little $100 Kodak point and shoot (which got too much sea moisture in it and died a horrible death after 3 years). I learned to manipulate it well and it gave me brilliant ribbon winning photos just as you have done with yours.
I do like my new camera, but I’ll be getting another small point and shoot because, hey life isn’t about the biggest, baddest camera – it’s about what you can do with what you have in your hands at just that moment.
Keep shooting…….I love your work! You have a great eye for composition and you will continue to turn out fabulous stuff now matter what camera you use!
Hey, I came here after seeing your work on PW’s site. Your work is just beautiful! After seeing your shots, I was able to pick the right camera for me, the new Canon SX10IS. I love it – and because I see the shots YOU take, I hold out hope that mine will improve. They’re already tons better than they used to be, mainly because the camera makes them pretty enough to keep me encouraged to take more. (Brief note: I know NOTHING about photography, like, NADA, ZILCH, ZIP).
Anyhoo, wanted to let you know how much I love your pictures. Also, after your jaw-dropping exercise between Canon/Nikon DSLRs, I had a question… the Beijing video was shot with a Canon camera BUT the lenses were all Nikon. So do we credit Canon or Nikon with the quality? (See, I told you I understand nothing about photography!). I’m curious because PW once posted a side-by-side comparison or photos she took with both, and the Nikon looked a bit punchier and crisper to me, like the footage in that Chinese video.
Thanks for reading this and for keeping the hope afloat for Point-and-Shooters!
Oh it’s so good to see I’m not the only one going through this. I’m about to hawk everything that isn’t tied down to upgrade to a DSLR (and I can’t even claim to have a valid reason outside of pure dabbledom – nor have I honestly tried to bend my point and shoot to do anything remotely good). But those practical concerns aside, it keeps coming back to budget budget budget…. I”m leaning into Canon territory for that reason alone. But then, will I regret it? Will I have forever wondered if I had just spent a little (or couple hundred) more? (Waa? Economy? hugh? Crisis? hugh? Didn’t hear that…) Can’t wait to hear what you finally decided. Love your site btw. You’re a great writer!
Timely [for me] discussion… I’ve been using the S3 IS for 2 years and inspired to use manual mode by PW and lately you, Ivory Hut.
Still, wanted to try a dslr and have been reading and dithering and dithering and reading. I ultimately decided that I liked the range of the Canon L lenses and I love my S3 and the control layout and as I compared Nikon and Canon I continued to feel more comfortable with Canon’s setup…so Canon…although I was severely tempted by the D300 and the D90 at Costco!!!
Finally decided on the Rebel xsi body to start (good reviews, great price and it takes the L lenses) with the thought that I would buy L series lenses as budget allowed and if/when I want and can upgrade.
I have had the xsi which I bought as the kit – getting the 18-55 EFS lens ($100 lens – about $80 more for the kit than without). Then I ordered the 17-40 L lens and discovered that on the Rebel, the width I am getting is very similar to the 18-55 and I’m getting slightly more zoom with the 55. Now, the 17-40 is a pro lens and I imagine on fine prints there is a lot noticeable – but for my purposes and current ability I decided I wanted to spend my lens money on something else. I returned the 17-40 and have ordered the 70-300 – not an L – but budget worthy for the moment and giving me a lot of range in 2 lenses.
A long story to say that back of my mind, loving my S3 and it’s lens range…the new S10 IS at $350ish – made me go with the non- L zoom so as to have not as much $$ invested as I’m wondering if ultimately, I will prefer the no fooling around scenario.
Flip side is I REALLY love looking through the lens. My 53 year old eyes are much happier and I’m getting more consistent images that are what I expect. I’ve been carrying both the Rebel and the S3 as the S3 has more zoom – and after using the Rebel, somewhat frustrating to use the S3 view.
I DO miss the articulating LCD from the S3 – why don’t they do that on the slrs?? I use it all the time for holding the camera high or low or sometimes a different angle.
At any rate, I agree – it is a very exciting time to be in photography and I appreciate all you teach and show Ivory Hut!
There is a site I enjoy for reviews and info: The Luminous Landscape http://www.luminous-landscape.com/
A great lens discussion (Canon) at:
http://www.luminous-landscape.com/ and there are links to corresponding Nikon lens discussion/review.
This site is practical, common sense info – not “evangelistic” for either “side” or any technique and basically says “get whateever you can”, get out there and enjoy shooting – which is the point…
LOL, it was like You wrote exactly what goes on in my head any time there is a major purchase to be had. Except that extra voice, the nagging one….Its my husband saying “don’t you already have a camera?” “But I want a new one, a better one!” “It takes pics doesn’t it?” I sigh and say yeah.
We are going to Hawaii in about a month and I making myself crazy researching all the stuff to do while we’re there lest we miss out on one thing!
Hi Maura! I completely agree with you. There’s nothing like actually handling the camera.
Natalie, good choice on the sx10! Even I was tempted by its 20x optical zoom badness. And good observation on the video stats, and the question about who gets credit for it is a legitimate one. (Which shows that you DO know more than zilch about photography.) But take a look at the second video, which was shot with Canon lenses, and you’ll clearly see that the incredible video is really a camera thing. So kudos to Canon.
Robyn, thanks for dropping by. It’s a harrowing mental debate, isn’t it? Glad to know I’m not alone.
Ann, that’s a great site. I’ve been following them for a long time now, and always check out their reviews. Thanks for your comment. A lot of it makes sense, and I intend to try out some of my old film lenses on the xSi just to see how it performs with those.
That said, I want to go on record saying that I still think my S5 with its Raynox DCR-250 macro converter lens can more than hold its own against other more professional setups. Which is why I’m likely never parting with it. Ever. (Natalie, if you’re into macro shots, you’ll have a blast with that Raynox. 20x zoom on that would be some crazy magnification!)
C.Kay, enjoy Hawaii! I spent some time in Maui many years ago, pre-Canon S5. All I had was an old Powershot A40, and brought home some wonderful shots. Hawaii’s good like that.
Brc, thanks for the vote of confidence. I never thought I’d relish a compliment that included the phrase “scary crazy.” Haha!
Thanks for the response…. yeah, the second video was so impressive! And I think my X-mas list will have to include that macro lens now. Okay, going now before I decide that I need extra equipment more than my kids need Xmas gifts LOL…
Oh – please stay with your point and shoot. All the beautiful pictures that you take with it – it gives me hope that maybe one day, I might be almost as good as you are!
You just described my research project…. well, maybe it’s a little different.
I bought a Canon 20D w/ a 70-200mm f/2.8 IS USM lens for sports (i.e. rodeo) pictures.
I found that every one that shot Nikon had much more brilliant pics than mine. (I called a camera guy and asked how to duplicate the “Vivid” setting in Canon and he said to up the Saturation…hasn’t worked for me yet.)
Then, I see Vincent Laforet’s video (I look at his blog most every day, too), and now the Canon 5D MK II is on my 2010 Christmas list.
I noticed that most of the pro’s at the Olympics this year used Canon. Most of the landscape/portrait photographers (check out http://www.greglatza.com ) use Nikon.
There are many times that I wish I had a point-n-shoot like yours for portable reasons… more portable, more pictures taken and that’s what it’s all about, right?
Thanks again for sharing.
Natalie, that’s what’s great about the Raynox DCR-250. Its price doesn’t really break the bank. If you get one, you’ll need a lens adapter tube as well. It’s around $5 on eBay. If you do get that macro setup, drop me a line. I have tons of tips to share with you.
Libby, not to worry. I’m not letting go of my S5.
So far, compared to the DSLR, I find the S5 has taken superior moon shots, and macro shots. Plus, I can leave home with just the S5 and not have to worry about lugging lenses.
PG, I actually thought most landscape photographers use Canon, especially since they were the first ones with the full-frame DSLR. Thanks for the Greg Latza link. Awesome photos.
I am so glad you haven’t gone over to the “other side” yet!
If one can capture great shots like yours with a PnS, it’s a no brainer and no wallet pincher too!
I’ll just keep drooling over Ashton…er his camera while I perfect working with what I’ve got.
Another point-and-shoot girl here, but I’m really hankering for a digital slr. I’m currently saving for a Canon, but it might take me a while. *sigh*
Dear Miss IvoryHut,
Please, no matter what you decide to do on the dSLR question, please do not stop shooting with and writing great tutorials for the Canon S5 IS. After reading your very first tutorial on PW, I went out that very weekend and bought that very camera. Yes, I had gone through the excruciating research you describe in looking for a “new” and “better camera”. I was all set to go for the Canon Xsi, or the Nikon D40, D60 or whatever….then you showed me I needn’t go there when I clearly wasn’t ready.
Based completely on your blog and tutorials, I bought the S5 IS (it was the last one the store had- the new Sx10 was coming in) got a good price on it and have been in love ever since! Even got a decent moon shot – thanks to your tutorial and suggestions.
I can understand your need to move on, but I also know what you mean about leaving your S5 IS behind having its feelings hurt. Prior to this purchase, I’ve been shooting with a Canon SD 700 IS, and I can tell you, it’s feelings are not hurt. It is still always by my side in my purse, and BECAUSE of this wonderful new camera I have, and all the things you’ve taught me, I’m even taking better pictures with the SD 700!
So I feel that even when you to on to the dSLR status, you will still continue to use and support (and can I hope to continue to write tutorials) for the S5 IS! It’s a great camera and I still have much to learn!
Happy Thanksgiving!
Funny, Terri! Given that I’m about as clumsy as Ashton is in that commercial, it just may be a bit dangerous for me to be using his camera.
Karen, I go through a “I really, really want a DSLR” phase about once or twice a year. That’s been going on for a few years now.
Sarah, excellent choice on the S5.
And yes, new things we learn about photography translate across the board regardless of what camera we’re using. I’m glad you’re having fun with your new camera. Keep shooting!
Hello Ms. Ivoryhut!
I followed you here from P-Dub’s site, and must say that in 2 days, you’ve pretty much answered all the initial questions I’ve always had regarding advanced photography. I’ve usually attempted to read books & manuals, and only ended up glassy eyed and befuddled by the end of the second paragraph. But I guess I can wrap my brain around water, and buckets and hoses pretty well.
Must be ‘cuz I’ve got kids…..
Santa is bringing me the Canon Powershot XS10 IS tomorrow (12/4) with a couple of tripods, and I’m sure by the end of the holidays, my family will be absolutely sick of me shoving the camera in their faces! With everything I’ve learned from you & P-Dub, I’m not so scared that my indoor shots will be dark & dreary, or that my outdoor shots will be dull & noisy. Thanks for taking the time to share your knowledge!!
And I’m glad to read that you’ll remain devoted to your S5.
Devoted,
Shawn
I’ve been a hardcore Nikon fan since the late 80’s … I admit I had a brief affair with a Canon but I broke it off shortly after.
I enjoyed the debate. I use a simple point and shoot now and want to become a more serious photographer… which this camera just doesn’t allow. I have been debating between the two for a year now. I have the same voices as you do… that is why I still haven’t purchased one.